Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mark Fernquest's avatar

So glad to hear this.

@economist's avatar

Frustrating to listen to the “non-profit” experts preach solutions to costly housing in Sonoma County. Data tells a different story. First, compared to building a 2,000 square foot “standard finish” house (land excluded) in St George Utah, Sebastopol is literally twice as costly - $414K/ St George and $868K/ Sebastopol. “Incentivize Affordability” – right sizing fees and adopting fees based on square footage sounds great on the surface, but fees are only 8% of building costs in Sebastopol. Labor makes up the biggest difference – 80%+. There is no discussion about steps to reduce the cost of labor.

Sebastopol has a robust pipeline of already approved new homes. There are currently 135 approved homes in Sebastopol that are not built. Most have been “approved” for a least 4 years, but developers have been reluctant to pull the trigger. If we are serious about new housing, why are city officials or non-profits not working with developers to understand and resolve issues and get them under construction. Seems more practical than just talking.

Sebastopol should be used as an example of a community that has been successfully improving the low-income housing situation for many years. Currently ½ of the residences in the city are rentals. 1/3 of them are deed restricted low income. Currently Sebastopol offers 427 restricted units. Given only 1.88 square miles and about 3,000 residences the city is doing more (for its size) for affordable housing than any other city in the county.

Lastly, “transit focused housing” comes up frequently as a solution. In this article and as the planning commission looks at reducing parking requirements for new development downtown. Sebastopol has no effective transit. There is one bus an hour to Santa Rosa. According to the 2023 census, 7 people used it per day.

While larger cities and the county with lots of available land should be prioritizing new development, with 1.88 square miles of fully developed land that is already straining the existing aging infrastructure, Sebastopol should not get distracted by these well-meaning idealists. Sebastopol needs to focus on balancing the city budget.

For 20 years the city has subsidized government with money from water rate payers. Every tax increase came with a promise it was needed to repair aging infrastructure. For whatever reason the city budget continues to be in deficit, there is still not sufficient money to repair streets. The neglected library is closed for water leaks and mold. The city recently announced it has to borrow $5MM to replace the 70-year-old water well, with interest costs effectively doubling the actual cost of the replacement. These are real problems that will eventually, if not addressed, bring the city down.

20 more comments...

Ready for more?