This is Part 1 of a two-part article.
Because the council voted to skip its Nov. 3 meeting due to the election, this week’s Sebastopol City Council meeting had such a packed agenda that the city decided to start the meeting an hour early. That didn’t help much. There were two longish presentations and 12 items (some quite controversial) on the regular agenda. Predictably, by the end of the evening, the council had only gotten about halfway through its agenda.
Part 1 of this article discusses proposed changes to bus service in Sebastopol, the removal of the sunset clause from the city’s Just Cause Eviction ordinance, two special event fee waivers, and a contract with 4LEAF, Inc., for planning director services. Part 2 will cover the council’s decision on a couple of water and sewer issues and the reconsideration of the ADU condominiumization ordinance.
Mayor Jill McLewis, Vice Mayor Sandra Maurer, Councilmember Phill Carter, Councilmember Neysa Hinton, and Councilmember Stephen Zollman were present in chambers for the Nov. 17 Sebastopol City Council meeting.
Quick look at the Consent Calendar
The consent calendar consists of items that are routine in nature or don’t require additional discussion, often because they’ve been discussed at a previous council meeting. If a council member thinks an item deserves more discussion, it is added to the end of the regular agenda.
In addition to approving the minutes of earlier meetings, the council unanimously approved the following:
Conflict of Interest Code: The council approved the required biennial review and update of the city’s Conflict of Interest Code, which requires officials to disclose financial interests through Form 700 filings.
Sonoma County Hazard Mitigation Plan: The council adopted the 2026 Sonoma County Hazard Mitigation Plan to maintain Sebastopol’s eligibility for FEMA hazard mitigation grants. Adoption does not commit the city to funding or implementing specific projects.
Well 4 Mitigation and Replacement Project: The council approved an amendment to the agreement with Luhdorff & Scalmanini Consulting Engineers (LSCE) to begin Phase 2 design work on the Well 4 Mitigation and Replacement Project. The cost of Phase 2 is estimated at up to $261,454 with a 5% contingency ($13,073).
At Vice Mayor Sandra Maurer’s request, two items were moved to the regular agenda for discussion later in the evening:
Special Event Permit Fee Waivers: For the last year or so, requests to waive city event permit fees for nonprofit events have come before the council almost every month, often after the event has taken place. The council invariably grants all or part of the fee waiver request. This item would direct staff to develop a policy for waiving special event permit fees and return to council with options and recommendations, including estimates of potential lost revenue based on past events.
Staff Recognition and Proclamations: Put forward by Councilmember Hinton, this item would amend the City Council protocols to restore dedicated time for staff recognition and proclamations during the Presentations portion of the agenda, with three minutes allotted for each recognition/proclamation and an additional three minutes for honorees’ comments.
While these two items were added to the end of the regular agenda, they never got discussed because the council only made it halfway through the agenda before the witching hour of 10:30 pm.
Presentations
There were two presentations: an annual report from Gold Ridge Fire Chief Schroth-Cary and Deputy Chief Dave Bray, and a presentation by Emily Betts of Sonoma County Transit, about proposed bus route changes in Sebastopol and elsewhere to align buses more closely with the SMART train.
Gold Ridge Fire Protection District Update
We will be doing a longer story soon based on the Gold Ridge District’s report to the council. For now, here are some quick statistics: district-wide, there are 135 volunteer members who worked more than 19,700 hours in 2026; 55 paid 24-hour shift personnel, including three battalion chiefs and five administrative positions: the fire chief, the deputy chief, and three administrative staff.
Regarding Station 83, the Sebastopol Station, Schroth-Cary said, “I think it’s worth pointing out that you have three career staff and one stipend volunteer, so affording four personnel, which is remarkable and only made possible by the volunteer staffing and the combination fire department that we are.”
In terms of response times, the district as a whole is at 7:15 (meaning 7 minutes and 15 seconds), with paid stations at 6:25 and the Sebastopol Station at 4:42.
Sonoma County Transit update
Sonoma County Transit (SCT) is changing many of its routes around the county to better align with the schedule of the SMART train and to cut back on routes that are duplicative with city-owned bus routes.
In Sebastopol, for Route 24 (the free bus), SCT is getting rid of the short loop so that every loop will run the full route.
Here’s a summary of proposed changes:
The Lucky’s parking lot stop will be removed, but Sonoma County Transit is considering adding up to five other stops, including Gravenstein Highway at Redwood Marketplace, at Keating and Pitt avenues, at Florence near Bodega, at Pleasant Hill near Ragle Road, and at Ragle Road at Mill Station. These additions are still under review.
SCT spends $800,000 a year for the 24 bus route, and Sebastopol pays $4,000 a year to make ridership free. The most frequently used stops are Burbank Housing, the transit hub by Rialto Theaters, and Safeway.
Regular Agenda
Removal of the sunset clause from Sebastopol’s Just Cause Eviction and Tenant Relocation ordinance
In response to the attempt by the developer of Woodmark Apartments to evict its low-income, non-farmworker tenants, the City Council adopted a Just Cause Eviction and Tenant Relocation ordinance in November of last year. The ordinance had a sunset clause of Jan. 1, 2027, and this item proposed removing the sunset clause altogether. Several residents of Woodmark and their advocates spoke in favor of this change.
Woodmark resident Sandie Russell thanked the council, city manager and city attorney for all their work on this ordinance and urged them to make it permanent. “Thank you for bringing this up again. We really, really appreciate it, and we will not forget. Believe me, we've worked so hard to stay where we live, and so far so good.” She said she felt that the City’s Just Cause Eviction ordinance was the main reason that the developer stopped trying to evict them.
Kate Bybee from Sonoma County Legal Aid said, “I want to say I think this is a really incredible example of the power of local government and what it can do in people’s lives. A year ago, 14 families living at Woodmark were facing the imminent loss of their homes, and this council chose to stand with those families. You chose to act and use the tools you had available at your disposal, and because of that, and because you closed this gap that exists in state law, it means [those] 14 families are still living at Woodmark. They have children who are able to stay in their schools, with their teachers, with their friends; families who’ve been able to hold on to that stability that they found there in a home that for many of those families was something that they had worked for and waited for a very, very, very long time.”
The council voted unanimously to remove the sunset clause on the ordinance.
Fee waivers granted for Trashlantis and Turkey Trot
This item involved waiving permit fees for the Trashlantis Festival, which happened in October, in the amount of $1,800, and the Kiwanis Turkey Trot, which is scheduled for Thanksgiving morning, in the amount of $400. While the council unanimously approved these requests, Councilmember Hinton said she was frustrated that her request to change the approval process to make it more timely had been continually delayed for months.
Council approves a contract for $249,375 for 1,248 hours of professional planning services from 4LEAF, Inc.
For much of the past three years, after longtime planning director Kari Svanstrom moved out of state, the city of Sebastopol has contracted out its planning services to 4LEAF, Inc. The city hired a permanent combined planning/community development director in early 2025, but that hire only lasted six months or so. The city has been contracting with 4LEAF and searching for a permanent replacement ever since.
This was supposed to be a simple renewal of the 4LEAF contract, but it turned into a larger discussion about the central role a planning director plays in creating a guiding vision for the city. First, Councilmember Zollman mentioned a letter he’d received from Lars Langberg, the chair of the city’s Design Review Board (DRB).
In that letter, Langberg noted that “the relationship between the work of the board and the Planning Dept has been less collaborative and effective.”
“More importantly,” Langberg wrote, “the City as a whole has suffered from the lack of vision that a Planning Director can provide. This includes developing the Work Plan for the DRB that was requested by the Council, as well as a more robust defense of important new housing laws like AB1033,” he wrote. “It became clear through the review of the project at 8100 Valentine that we need more wide-ranging objective design standards. The volunteers of the DRB could work on that, just as they are working on a revised tree ordinance. But without a full-time planning director to lead that effort, it would take a lot longer and not hold as clear a vision.”
In response, City Manager Mary Gourley detailed the City’s multi-year effort to find a new planning director. This included the failed permanent hire and multiple hiring rounds that ended with candidates failing the job knowledge test for that position.
In public comment, Paul Fritz, a member and former chair of the Planning Commission, echoed Langberg’s assessment.
“It has been a frustration of mine that we’ve had four planning directors in the past three years. I’ve been a longtime member of the planning commission, and there’s a number of items that I’ve been wanting to accomplish from our work plan,” he said. “Every time we get a new planning director, I sit down with them and kind of bring them up to speed, and then that happens again, and I bring them up to speed … There has been a list that John Gray and I came up with over three years ago now that literally nothing on that list has been accomplished, and I find that it’s really problematic.
Michell Kelly asked what the tests that were giving candidates such trouble were testing for. Gourley said it tests knowledge of CEQA, California housing code, and how to do project applications, etc.
Ted Luthin, a former member of the Design and Review Board, echoed the “vision” sentiment. “A planning director is the keeper of the vision of the city,” he said. “That’s what they do, and without them, we don’t move things forward. We might process applications. We might be able to do the nuts-and-bolts stuff with an outside consultant, but … you’re not going to have that cohesive vision.”
He then listed several projects—the Rotary project at Ives, the Commons project—that might not have gone off the rails had a full-time planning director been in place.
One commenter noted that the city was paying roughly $250,000 (the cost of a full-time planning director salary) for significantly less than full-time hours.
In response to complaints about projects not getting done, Gourley said that her staff (contract or not) had completed a lot of projects. “We do not believe that we are holding up projects,” She mentioned the completion of the housing element, the revival of the PDA grant, and the fee schedule update. “We have a lot of projects in place that we’re continuing to do, as well as our routine planning applications.”
She emphasized that the search for a planning director was ongoing, but noted that the 4LEAF contract was expiring and the city needed someone to do the job until a full-time person could be found.
With little choice, the city council unanimously approved the 4LEAF contract.
Part 2 of this article will cover the council’s decision on a couple of water and sewer issues and the reconsideration of the ADU condominiumization ordinance.
You can watch the video of the Nov. 17 Sebastopol City Council meeting here. The next Sebastopol City Council meeting is Dec. 1, 6 pm, at the Sebastopol Youth Annex, 425 Morris St., Sebastopol, and on Zoom.






Are you going to cover the ice raids in Sebastopol?
Please feel better quickly.